![](https://protoolsuserblog.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/c7c22-img.jpg?w=625)
Here’s an open question for you – how do you know that your track is finished?
For me its usually when the client is happy with the work and signs it off. If I’m happy too then that’s a bonus. Maybe you’re in a band so everyone needs to be happy. That’s trickier and I’ve noticed over the years that some of the best bands out there have a hierarchy, where certain members quietly lead the process. Often but not always, it’s the songwriters. If that’s what is needed to get an album finished – a good balance of band politics – then it’s worth giving it some thought and think ‘maybe I should back down, or ‘maybe I should step up’…
There are plenty of hurdles before the finish line: indecision, fear of criticism, even thinking that your gear is not ‘pro’ enough so it can’t be released yet. Whatever they might be for you, I think its valuable to recognize what they are, and whether they are really a good enough reason to not wrap it up and move on.
Perfectionism Is Less Than Perfect
If starting a project is hard, then finishing an idea can be even harder. Perfectionism is one of the biggest barriers for the developing writer. The need for things to be perfect can become a horrendous feedback loop whereby you trawl over the same ideas again and again, never quite satisfied with the result, and crucially not moving forward either. Of course we all want things to be the very best they can be – but it is very important to keep moving forward too.
Just like the work quantity vs. best work ratio, this is a major balancing act. When you do find yourself in that feedback loop of tweaking and tinkering I find its best to either just end it and say its done [very difficult but sometimes necessary] or to deliberately shelve the idea and allocate time to it later when you can approach it from a fresh perspective. It’s a very personal thing of course, but if a need for perfection is holding you back from releasing anything then you have a problem. If you’re a producer then your job title literally indicates that a finished product is on the horizon, and that’s the role when you produce for others so why not if you self-produce?
The Law Of Diminishing Returns
The phrase ‘good enough’ doesn’t have a great ring to it. However it doesn’t necessarily need to mean something is bad. It can actually be very liberating to realize that not everything needs to be completely perfect. In fact the effort to perfect a track might lead to a drain in what was interesting in it in the first place. I know that these days there’s a certain amount of expectation that music is tuned and airbrushed, but there’s also still a real appetite for stuff that’s a little rough and ready too. You can spend an awful lot of time doing those tiny tweaks, especially in the early days. But there’s often a point where the tweaks are just not worth it, and if you’re unlucky the process throws itself into reverse and you proceed in making things worse. If you keep your wits about, you can sense that change and do something about it.
The Rear View Mirror
I’ve got stacks of recordings I’ve made over the years. Two track cassettes, four track cassettes, Zip drives.. You get the idea. I wouldn’t play them all to you because frankly some of them are properly awful. Some of them are not bad, but the point is that they all represent steps on a journey to doing better work. I’ll sometimes have a go at updating the odd tune, with varied success but that’s just the way it goes. For creators, writers, and producers there’s just no simple formula to follow. The best we can hope for is good guiding principles that can be applied when we need them. Whether you’re a seasoned professional or an aspiring writer I think its vital to break down your process now and again – to figure what works and to think about how you can make improvements.
“Art is never finished, only abandoned” – Leonardo Da Vinci
We all navigate our own path, and we all somehow manage to get in our own way sometimes. It would be great to hear about your strategies for getting over the finish line. If you feel you have something valuable to add to the community, post your thoughts in the comments below.